Is Trump Wine Worth the Hype? Current Scores and Critic Reviews

Donald Trump’s venture into the wine industry has stirred up quite a buzz. Trump Winery, located in Charlottesville, Virginia, aims to produce wines that reflect the unique terroir of the region. But how does this winery’s portfolio hold up under scrutiny? Let’s examine the latest scores and critiques to see if Trump wine is worth the investment.

Trump Winery Overview

Established in 2011, Trump Winery is situated on a sprawling estate in Virginia’s renowned wine country. The winery produces a variety of wines, including Chardonnay, Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, and blends. The focus is on creating wines with regional character, but opinions on their success are varied.  I have written extensively on the winery.  Please see previous blog posts.  

Notable Varietals and Vintages

1. Trump Chardonnay 2021

Score: 90 Points – Wine Enthusiast

The Trump Chardonnay 2021 has received praise for its vibrant and refreshing profile. According to Wine Enthusiast, this vintage features “bright citrus notes of lemon and lime, with a hint of vanilla and a smooth, creamy texture.” It’s lauded for its balance and versatility, making it a great match for seafood or poultry.

2. Trump Merlot 2020

Score: 88 Points – Wine Advocate

The Trump Merlot 2020 has been described as “fruit-forward with flavors of ripe plum and cherry, complemented by subtle notes of oak.” Wine Advocate appreciates its “smooth tannins and approachable style,” though it notes that the finish is somewhat short. It’s a solid choice for casual drinking or pairing with everyday meals.

3. Trump Cabernet Sauvignon 2019

Score: 91 Points – Wine Spectator

The Trump Cabernet Sauvignon 2019 stands out for its depth and complexity. Wine Spectator highlights its “dark fruit flavors of blackberry and cassis, with undertones of coffee and spice.” This vintage is praised for its “structured tannins and long, satisfying finish,” making it a recommended pick for those who enjoy a robust, full-bodied red.

4. Trump Reserve 2018

Score: 93 Points – Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate

The Trump Reserve 2018 has garnered high acclaim from Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate. The review notes its “elegant layers of blackcurrant, cedar, and a touch of graphite.” This premium blend is described as “well-structured and age-worthy,” showcasing the potential for high-quality winemaking at Trump Winery.

Critical Consensus

Trump Winery’s latest releases reflect a commitment to quality, with several wines receiving high praise from critics. The Chardonnay and Cabernet Sauvignon, in particular, have been noted for their impressive balance and depth. While some wines like the Merlot have received more modest reviews, the overall trend indicates a winery on the rise.  I am a fan of the Meritage.  

Whether you’re intrigued by the Trump brand or simply interested in exploring Virginia’s wine offerings, Trump Winery’s current portfolio provides a range of options worth tasting. As always, personal preference--not to mention party affiliation--plays a significant role, so sampling these wines will help you determine if they align with your taste and politics.